The 400-adult homeless shelter on West 95th street.
An article this month from New York magazine reveals stark and disturbing facts about the family that has profited off of the proliferation of homeless shelters on the Upper West Side, and been aided in their goals by the Bloomberg administration.
We’ve written several articles about the problems with the shelter at 316 and 330 West 95th street, where operators Aguila Inc. make $3,700 per tiny cubicle per month. But we really had no idea quite how bad things were until reading the article about the landlords behind many of the local shelters, including the one on 95th. The Podolskys, who own many of the buildings here that are now used as shelters, have a startling history of forcing poor people out of their homes in order to make money off of city policies that reward the nastiest kind of abuse. How startling? The brothers in charge of the real estate have 37 felonies on their record stemming from some pretty startling abuses. They’ve been called “terror lords.”
“In 1983, the Podolskys and another family partnered to purchase three connected buildings on West 77th Street. What happened next caught the attention of Morgenthau’s office. According to prosecutors, after some preliminary hostilities with tenants, the Podolskys hired ‘professional vacators,’ a gang that traveled Manhattan in a U-Haul truck, rendering buildings unlivable. A leader called “Bear” was allegedly installed as the superintendent, and apartments were filled with hustlers, prostitutes, and junkies. Tenants reported frequent burglaries and harassment. One elderly woman died of pneumonia in an unheated room. The vacators received $600 for each departing tenant. They were friendly with all three Podolskys, prosecutors claimed. When Zenek visited, Bear would wash his Cadillac.”
The article makes it clear that this was not an isolated event from long ago. Author Andrew Rice details more recent incidents of poor people in other buildings living in absolute filth and being evicted in all sorts of disturbing ways. By pushing out poor people who pay lower rents, they get to invite homeless people in and make ten times as much. Meanwhile, some of the poor people they push out become homeless. “The Podolskys had hit upon a coldly self-sustaining business model: They created the homeless supply and profited from the shelter demand.” The shelter buildings also have violations that the city simply overlooks.
The city and the landlords have kept these facts well hidden, failing to respond to questions from the media and local leaders and sometimes running shelters in private buildings without any contracts at all. The Podolskys’ shelter business “operates behind a firewall of arcane lease arrangements and interrelated holding companies, many of which have been placed in the maiden names of the brothers’ wives, Shirley and Sharon.” And Aguila executives like Robert Hess (the former DHS commissioner), and middlemen like Alan Lapes appear to be front men for the landlords, who make tons of money on the contracts — $90 million or more since 2010. (Interestingly, the Podolskys also own upscale hotels like the Empire Hotel.)
What’s more, there appear to be many more shelters than we had originally known about. The Podolskys appear to have connections to shelters on West 83rd street and throughout the 90’s and 100’s, according to a map compiled by New York magazine. We’ve posted the UWS portion below, and you can see the entire map here.
This would seem to be the kind of abuse that government officials would aggressively fight. But the Bloomberg administration has fought aggressively to protect the Podolskys, spending taxpayer money on lawyers to fight for them and their front men. The city lawyers are now in court against Comptroller John Liu and local group Neighborhood in the Nineties. As local leaders can attest, Liu has been the most aggressive city official when it comes to calling Bloomberg out on this issue.
We reached out to City Council member Gale Brewer and State Assembly member Linda Rosenthal for comments about the article, but haven’t heard anything back. Although they have opposed the shelters, local politicians often seem to be in the dark about what’s really going on (to be fair, Bloomberg has done everything he can to stop oversight). Helen Rosenthal, who will be taking over for Brewer next month, has vowed to change the system. Bill de Blasio has also pledged a change. We will be keeping tabs to see what happens.
Anyway, go read the magazine article. It’s stunning. Here’s our coverage of the homeless shelter issue.
The map above shows locations of homeless shelters tied to the Podolsky family on the UWS, as identified by New York magazine. Full map is here.
Our “beloved” Upper West Side councilwoman Gale Brewer let much of this happen under her watch, so it’s no wonder that she hasn’t responded. Do you see that cluster of homeless shelters around 94th & 95th street? I live nearby, and lately I haven’t been able to walk around my own neighborhood without being asked for money. See the cluster around 100th street? Adjacent store owners complain that they are losing business because their own customers are uncomfortable walking through groups of loiterers in front of the shelters to get to their stores. I have tried many times to contact Gale Brewer, Scott Stringer, and my own Community Board 6 about this growing problem. Nobody, even their proxies, have given me the decency of a response. Perhaps others on this site will have better luck!
Oh, the indignity. People actually ask you for money?
Okay, Jane. How about being begged, cajoled, and harassed for money, not to mention getting dangerously close to my family while we are simply trying to walk home. Is that indignant enough for you?
be careful what you wish for….. too bad these are not actual hotels anymore right?
https://www.columbiaspectator.com/2007/09/21/tenants-celebrate-closure-illegal-hotel
Buried deep in the New York magazine article is a one-paragraph clue as to the human trash that the patriarch of the Podolsky clan is:
“The story of the family business traces back to … a hardened patriarch. Zenek Podolsky was born in Poland in 1920. Most of his family was killed at Treblinka. He later recounted, in a testimony for the Shoah Foundation, that he survived the Holocaust by working for the Gestapo as a mechanic, then on a crew commanded by the Jewish Police. His job involved traveling “city by city, cleaning out the Jewish neighborhoods” after their occupants had been deported. “They gave me a torch,” he said, “and made me in charge of opening up the safes.”
In other words, Zenek saved himself by becoming not only a Nazi collaborator but a hoodlum. It’s easy to understand the “values” he later inculcated in his offspring. And, after years of ripping off the City of New York this trash retired to…Florida, leaving his children to carry on his work, which they did, enjoying the life-style of the over-the-top nouveau riche (read the article).
And from people like this we expect normal behavior and morality? HAH!
My guess is that if you follow the money you will discover why none of the politicians respond or do anything about this mess.
What happened? Our formally wonderful city is being transformed by the powerful and the corrupt who run the City into a nightmare of corruption and deceit.
Robert Hess, former DHS commissioner running the numbers game! …Prick.
This city has always been about corruption and deceit. Run by the powerful. Nothing new here, unfortunately. Back to the time of Boss Tweed and beyond.
THAN YOU WESTSIDE RAG!!
How much corruption of this nature is ignored by the press. Tons. It’s horrifying that Rosanthall and Brewer are wasting their time. It’s abhorrent that creeps like former DHS commissioner and his buddy Alan Lapes are protected by Bloomberg…. No wonder his assets went from 1.3 million in 2001 to 31million in 2011. Bastards all.
Why isn’t anyone ranting about the Bloomberg administration which is responsible for this facility as well as for the burgeoning homeless population in our city, not Gale Brewer or Linda Rosenthal, who are, “mere” progressive Democratic legislators facing a billionaire Republican Mayor (and please don’t try to tell me that Mayor Nike is an “independent”. Unless you have some evidence to support your accusation (and I did not read any), I would urge you to refrain from the inflammatory rhetoric and charges of “corruption”. I understand you are upset, and that it impacts your quality of life — believe me, I do. I’ve lived in Manhattan Valley for 37 years! By the way, Robert Hess, Bloomberg’s former Homeless Services Commissioner, and recent CEO of the suspect Housing solutions, died of cancer on Christmas Eve.
Elizabeth, you are correct – Bloomberg (of whom I’m a huge supporter) is absolutely at fault here. However, Brewer, Rosenthal, and Stringer still failed miserably in their jobs to secure the best interests of the neighborhood that the represent. Look at the empty storefronts, the failed plans (the Alamo Brewhouse for example), the stupid plans (JHL at Park West Village) a lack of development, and the increased seediness of the area north of 86th Street. Political rhetoric aside, at the very least these people did a crappy job, and because of their failures, our neighborhood has turned into an embarrasment.
You are blaming the Mayor for this too? I thought he only cared about the rich? you can’t have it both ways!
The fact is the ultra liberal left control this City – and rely on the good will and tax money of good natured new yorkers who really do not understand what happens in politics.
This problem is completely Gail and Linda’s creation. Period.
That and the extremists judges who make New York City the only place in America that is legally obligated to house everyone who demands it (new Yorker or not). This of course attracts moochers from across the country and world.
Add Gail’s law that made these upgraded hotels not legal as…..Hotels. – the silliness is that they are not “safe” for transients to stay overnight because of the lack of secondary egress in case of fire, but this is okay by code for monthly stays (does that make sense? no).
What where the owners to do if they can’t rent them out.
and yes the City should not be using our money for this, but that is what the judges require. This needs to be overruled bt wasn’t under mayor billionaire, so all hope is lost with a progressive (communist) mayor.
Go Ahead Bruce. Attack my truthful post.
You’re right: the NY Mag article is stunning. Worth reading the article comments, too. Some are actually informative. At this point, let’s hope our Mayor, DHS officials and city council members are pushed until they find an integrated solution to homeless people living on the street, affordable housing, and keeping the city a great place to live, do business in and visit as a tourist.
Because this process looked mainly like a way for Manhattan to look pristine for businesses and tourists–almost like Koch-era painting over tenement windows back when. The Podolsky tactics also sound like Robert Moses’ time.
Bad all over.
How is this legal??? How is the City paying all of this money into these disgusting places and not demanding any accountability? This is a concerted fraud, a conspiracy to steal public funds being committed and apparently Bloomberg was in on it. And are you telling me that this is just going to continue, no one is going to step in and STOP THIS???