This article was originally published on by THE CITY. Sign up here to get the latest stories from THE CITY delivered to you each morning.
By Claudia Irizarry Aponte and Gwynne Hogan, THE CITY
Newly arrived migrants living in city shelters celebrated news that the federal government will allow many Venezuelans to legally live and work in the United States — even as advocates and experts caution that relief will not be immediate.
“Now there are no excuses,” said Iker Luis Olivier, who has been living in a Midtown hotel with his wife and daughter since the family’s arrival to the United States in January. “We all have the opportunity to have working permits and find a job and don’t depend on the city.”
The federal Department of Homeland Security announced Wednesday night that the U.S. would extend Temporary Protected Status (TPS) to just under half a million Venezuelan migrants who have been living in the U.S. prior to July 31, a designation that grants those who crossed the border without legal documentation the right to obtain work permits and to live in the U.S. without fear of deportation.
While TPS will allow some Venezulans to skip the required 180-day waiting period before they can secure work permits, and presents a simpler application process than seeking asylum, experts caution the change in federal policy is far from an overnight solution.
Like many parts of the nation’s backlogged and overwhelmed immigration system, TPS and the related employment authorization that might come with it can take months for applicants to secure.
One immigrant advocacy group said it currently takes the federal government anywhere from three to nine months to issue work permits, even potentially for those who qualify for relief under the new order from President Joe Biden’s administration.
“We’re hoping it will improve but we have to await more details on the federal government’s [work permit] policy changes before we can know with greater certainty how this will play out,” said Make the Road spokesperson Daniel Altschuler.
The Asylum Seeker Advocacy Project, a New York City based nonprofit, warns applicants to expect months of delays, and explains approvals for work permits can sometimes come through quicker via the asylum application process than with TPS.
An estimated 40% of the more than 113,000 migrants who have arrived in the five boroughs since last year hail from the South American country, according to estimates from City Hall. While an estimated 24,000 Venezulans are currently living in city shelters, only about 15,000 of them are eligible for TPS based on the date of their arrival, according to Kayla Mamelak, a spokesperson for Mayor Eric Adams. All told 112,800 people, including 59,900 migrants were living in city shelters, through Sept. 10.
It’s unclear how many more Venezuelans living in New York, outside city shelters, might qualify for TPS if they’d arrived before the end of July.
Olivier is one of the few new arrivals who have filed paperwork to claim asylum. Though he submitted his application in June, he was still waiting the required 150-days before filing additional paperwork to apply for a work permit. He said he was hopeful applying for TPS would allow him to work legally much more quickly.
“It’s great news,” Olivier, who was an English teacher in his home country, said.
‘Clear Out the Shelters’
The vast majority of asylum seekers have yet to begin their asylum applications, and might not be aware about the latest changes to TPS that allows them to immediately apply for a work permit.
The federal and state government have chastised city officials for delays at helping people submit their applications, a precursor to helping them get working papers so they can move out of shelters. Aiming to address this, the city opened a center this summer, where migrants can get help filling out their applications. Through Sept. 13, however, the center had helped just 3,800 people apply.
Last week, city officials announced a “three-week sprint” to survey everyone in shelters to see if they were eligible for work permits right away under another wrinkle in federal immigration policy known as a humanitarian parole.
Honorario González, who arrived with a first wave of Venezuelan migrants last fall, learned of the TPS changes through a reporter from THE CITY, but said he was eager to find out more. The 38-year-old is still trying to find someone to help him fill out the complicated asylum application paperwork.
“It would change everything,” if he were granted legal permission to work, he said in Spanish. “I’d be able to have everything, pay rent and pay taxes and be legal. All of us want that.”
“That’s what we want: to work,” he added.
New York Governor Kathy Hochul said city, state, and federal workers would be coordinating in the coming days to identify Venezuelans in city shelters eligible to apply for TPS.
“We can start to clear out the shelters,” she said. “I thank the president for answering our call for help. This is an important first step.”
Mayor Adams responded with more muted praise. Speaking on CNN Thursday morning, he doubled down his insistence that migrants “will destroy New York City.”
“We’re getting 10,000 a month, and this surge may continue,” he said. “Since April, we’ve been calling for this, and I want to thank the congressional delegation, Congressman Hakeem Jeffries and Senator [Chuck] Schumer. But this is really moving in the right direction, but we have a long way to go.”
Permits for Wage Whistleblowing?
Meanwhile, New York unions and immigration advocates have also been quietly working behind the scenes to help newly arrived migrants and other undocumented workers involved in labor disputes to get legal protection and work permits under a different recent federal order.
Through rules announced by the federal DHS in January, undocumented workers who are victims of or witnesses to labor law violations can apply for immigration enforcement relief known as deferred action — and apply for a work permit, too. This includes newly arrived migrants from any country who are victims or witnesses to wage theft, workplace harassment and discrimination, workers compensation fraud, and other violations of labor law.
Undocumented workers entering the construction industry often end up in non-union work, where they are at greater risk of exploitation, severe injury or even death on the job.
Laborers’ Local 79, the construction worker union, is among the organizations helping migrants exposed to abuse on the job to secure work permits. Union head Mike Prohaska said that he hopes the rule will encourage undocumented workers to cooperate with law enforcement to expose wrongdoing.
“Undocumented workers in construction and other industries often fear retaliation from bosses, so they are hesitant to inform law enforcement agencies about abuses they face on the job,” he said. “We have seen this problem increase with the influx of new migrants and asylum seekers in New York.”
And some workers are already getting relief. Néstor Márquez has been battling a wage theft claim against a former employer in The Bronx for nearly five years, and claims he is owed more than $3,500 in lost wages.
Earlier this year, his case manager with Make the Road New York informed Márquez he was eligible for relief under the plan because of his pending wage theft claim with the state Department of Labor. He submitted the paperwork in February and, after nearly two decades in the U.S., received a legal work permit this summer.
“It feels lousy when an employer asks for your papers, and you tell them you don’t want to show them — because you don’t have them,” Márquez, who now lives in South Carolina, said in Spanish. “It feels good to be able to walk in with my head high and have the proper papers.”
Márquez joked that now that he has his work permit, he’s “not as bothered” by his lost wages, which he is still battling to recover. “If they hadn’t done that to me, I wouldn’t have my papers today.”
THE CITY is an independent, nonprofit news outlet dedicated to hard-hitting reporting that serves the people of New York.
You know, I can’t say whether this is a good idea or not because I am not certain what Biden and NY politicians are trying to accomplish in the medium and long term.
If they’re trying to drive the number of migrants up tenfold then they’re doing a great job and the work permits are the next logical step. You’ve now shown every would-be economic migrant than he’ll get a work permit if he can get here by making a BS asylum claim. Why on earth would he bother using any other means to immigrate here? Why hesitate to waltz right on in? In the short term I guess it puts a minimum wage in their pockets but where are they going to live now? The city is also having an affordable housing crisis that has no easy solution in sight.
It seems the Democrats are simply not prepared to admit that if you don’t lower the number of illegal immigrants and ‘asylum seekers’ who are allowed to stay here, you’re going to crash our already fragile social safety nets. I don’t see a way around that choice, unfortunately. Life is full of tough choices.
Oh, and the ‘temporary’ nature of the permits or permission to stay here on humanitarian grounds is just nonsense. If you can’t deport them now you won’t deport them in 18 months after they’re settling in.
Within history of Temporary Protected Status no persons covered under such designation has ever had said status formally revoked. This leaves aside those who have violated laws or otherwise run afoul of program.
Persons from San Salvador, Haiti, Somalia, Yemen, and others have been in USA for ten, twenty or more years under “temporary” status.
Program as designed is *NOT* temporary but each nation once given TPS status automatically renews unless officially withdraw.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Temporary_protected_status
These 500k Venezuelans have effectively immigrated to United States. They will never leave nor be compelled to long as TPS remains law in current form.
Let’s not forget lower wages, higher rents and increased income inequality once these illegal immigrants (yes, had they been asylum seekers they would have applied for asylum in Mexico, a country where hundreds of thousands of US citizens live and vacation every year), join the labor force.
Why don’t we change our asylum laws to require the asylum seeker apply from their country of origin? That way, if their claim isn’t valid, we don’t have to deport them. This seems like a common sense solution that won’t reward lawbreakers and those without valid claims. Let’s make sneaking across the border an automatic disqualification.
Admittedly, I have grown quite skeptical of govt intent. Problems that they can’t solve seem to be by design especially when there is money to be made or political power at stake. I do suspect that having a large critical mass of unemployed, uninsured, unhoused people in pressing need of govt services, wandering the streets of NYC, many with babies and small children, gives them much more leverage in passing new legislation and securing budget that otherwise would not even make it to the floor. If it is out of sight, it is out of mind. It always boils down to power, budget, and votes.
This is about the country as a whole. The one with close to 9 million job openings.
We need more immigrants and as long as it’s legal for people to come to the border and seek asylum we might as well put them to work in a legal fashion. IF we do that they can go where they’re needed and not where they’re coddled.
At some point the sane members of Congress will be able to write a law that will go a ways toward fixing the immigration issue which will clarify the asylum process while addressing the reality that we have too little “legal”immigration. But that’s a long way off.
In the interim our conservatives have been screaming for years that Venezuela is the new Cuba so why not treat the refugees from Venezuela the same as we treat the Cubans who escape that country?
Where are these jobs? I’m going to guess a good percentage of these jobs require one to speak English, have some education and training/skills. These jobs are in places with no public transit. There are no right to shelter laws outside of NYC. It’s not that simple. And it’s fascinating how no one cares this much about NYC born homeless. Migrants first Americans last. SMH.
You would guess wrong.
“The Post spoke with 36 migrants over a five-day period, of whom 65% said they were already taking off-the-books jobs in food service and delivery, construction or housekeeping — while city officials generally look the other way, The Post has learned.”
https://nypost.com/2023/09/20/illegal-underground-gig-economy-booms-in-nyc-as-migrants-await-work-permits-all-while-living-off-citys-dime/
Jobs are same illegal aliens have been doing in NYC and elsewhere in USA for decades. Just now businesses and others have a huge new pool of cheaper labor.
https://nypost.com/2023/09/21/longstanding-nyc-migrants-pushed-out-of-jobs-by-newcomers/
NYC has a huge service based economy. Large parts of it from construction, hospitality, janitorial and others are made up of illegal aliens.
Well, in Iowa they’re debating letting 14 year olds work in meat packing and in Arkansas they’re talking having 14 year olds working in the evenings in restaurants. So yes, the job openings are everywhere and guess what? Spanish speaking people have jobs in every state in the continental US.
BTW, there are plenty of people who get rides to work from friends and colleagues.
And where did you pull out the ‘no one cares’ about NYC born homeless?’ This city makes shelter, food, etc available to all homeless people on a walk in basis AND has teams of outreach staff dealing with those who don’t want shelter. Nobody is putting the migrants ahead of the homeless. SMH indeed.
Have you ever been to a homeless shelter? These migrants are in nice hotels. Homeless shelters are giant rooms with filthy bathrooms and disgusting food. There’s a massive difference.
That’s a good question. Why doesn’t Adams put the migrants in similar conditions? Why aliens are placed in better conditions than citizens ?
Single migrants are in tents.
Homeless families are, overwhelmingly, in apartment buildings not shelters.
Single migrants are in tents? Maybe some. Have been around 70s and Broadway when Stratford Arms hosted single migrants?
Categorizing Venezuelans as “economic migrants” feels misleading. The country is in a horrific state of collapse, with tens of thousands lost to extrajudicial executions and government sponsored crime syndicates. Their healthcare system has collapsed, disease is rampant, and starvation increasingly pervasive.
There’s much more driving this migration than simple economics.
So why are they not applying for asylum in Mexico or Columbia or Brazil?
@ Ding Dong — Yes and Yes. We truly need to revise our immigration policies, NOW !
This is very scary……. No mention of vetting any of these illegal immigrants. What is their background? Criminal record? Health record?
Yes. And recall how for two years the US wouldn’t let tennis star Djokovic into the country to play because he was unvaccinated. Yet we waive in a thousand unvaccinated migrants through our southern border each day and it’s no biggie!
Thank you. Needed to be said. Not to mention their unvaccinated children are allowed in the public school system while unvaccinated American children with medical and/or religious exemptions are unceremoniously kicked out.
The whole situation is a sad mess and unfortunately stems from the lack of a comprehensive and enforced immigration policy at a national level. That being said, all of these people are here, it is unsustainable for the city to keep paying for them and it is not good for them to just be sitting idle or selling mangos and candy in the subway, so they need to be able to legally work. I understand the arguments and concerns about this but I have to think that letting them legally work is better than continuing to pick up the tab and not letting them work. In the meantime the govt needs to be working on an actual solution for this.
Most migrants in the NYC shelters have not applied for asylum which is a predicate for obtaining work authorizations outside of TPS. Notably, if such asylum claim is not granted – there is a criminal check done and also an eval of whether the asylum standards are met – the applicant is referred for removal. Readers can decide for themselves why the asylum claims have not been filed.
WSR demanded that I make it clear that my comment is my opinion in order to consider posting it. Here it goes:
IN MY OPINION
Of course we understand that good percentage of migrants are here solely for freebies. They have no intention of filing the claim as it might be rejected eventually. Meanwhile they get free housing, medical care and food at our expense as long as they want. They message their friends and family to come and do the same.
Biden recommended that Adams “identifies” the ones eligible for filing asylum claims. So the city is proving free everything for these “asylum seekers” for no reason other than verbal claim of asylum seeking at the border. Actual filing of asylum claim can’t be forced. So we are paying for these migrants indefinitely. We are blatantly taken advantage of by the migrants and our own government.
We’re a country of mostly immigrants or descendants of. BUT – what’s the upper limit on numbers of migrants we citizens of NY are forced to pay for? Are New Yorkers going to provide free housing, food and various other services to the whole population of Venezuela … ?
The consequences of this “sanctuary city” thing are insane and yes, will wreck our city if the dollars continue to pour into a widening sinkhole. Meanwhile, providers are making money off this… and we are the ones paying.
Yes this crisis is going to cause big problems. The covid money is gone. Hotel rates are super high which is bad for tourism.
I’d like to try this again, and perhaps the “powers that be” will not censor me again. Although I must admit, I find it astonishing that WSR feels my comments, usually every other one, should not be published.
My last comment was regarding some of the remarks made by members of the House of Representatives. One person insisting that “the border IS NOT OPEN.” Another telling the reporter that Republicans should just “stop talking about it.” A third saying “what you see is different than what happens in actuality .”
Really? So they are telling us “are you going to believe us or your lying eyes?”
I keep wondering how this is going to impact lower income New Yorkers already looking for work (that will actually cover their bills).
I also wonder if the Mayor has considered bussing the migrants to DC the way TX bussed them here. Drop off several hundred thousand people in front of the White House. Maybe then Biden would find the resources to handle the mess he made.
(I assume there’s a reason this wouldn’t be legal – although TX got away with it.)
If that sounds heartless, well, how is letting undocumented people fend for themselves on the rat-infested NYC streets as cold weather approaches any better?
Regarding busing these folks CHOSE to come to NYC because of the free stuff. They weren’t forced to come here. TX didn’t get away with anything. Government funded charities are the ones paying for this transportation.
Want to clarify something.
One sees reference to “asylum to many of these migrants. Truth is huge numbers of those paroled into USA by Biden from places such as Venezuela are here based upon humanitarian reasons, not political asylum.
One huge reason why Biden back tracked and give these 500k Venezuelan migrants TPS status is that democrats and others in federal government knew or know 99.9% of them would not qualify for asylum. TPS was the only other option on table at that point.
You only have to read interviews with these migrants to hear one clear reason for coming to USA; they want to work. That is they are economic migrants, something not covered by asylum laws.