By Ed Hersh
Like many Upper West Siders, New York State Assembly Member Linda Rosenthal has watched the steady stream of asylum-seekers being bussed to New York City from our southern border states. They have been âtricked and essentially human trafficked,â Rosenthal told the Rag on Wednesday. âAs a child of immigrants myself, I feel we have an obligation to help these people.â
Many UWS residents clearly share her concern. After Rosenthal announced that, beginning October 3rd, she would collect warm clothes and baby supplies for migrant families at her office on West 72nd Street, âI admit I was a little overwhelmed. I knew people would be generous, but itâs a sea of clothes and books.â Â
That might be an understatement; when we visited the office every corner and surface seemed to be crammed with bags of donations from local residents and even, her staff told us, from as far away as Queens; her office estimates that at least 120 people have dropped off donations.
The city is scrambling to find shelter for the estimated 17,000 migrants that have been bussed in since April. Within Rosenthalâs district, there is a large group staying at the Skyline Hotel on 10th Avenue and 49th street, which is serving as a family shelter. According to the Daily News, âthe Skyline Hotel houses around 200 families with children, and about 40% of the residents are recent migrants from the southern border, many of whom were bused to the city from Texas by Gov. Greg Abbott.â Â Rosenthal believes there may be up to 100 newborn children among those families, many of whom are receiving care through Ryan Health, the local community health center. She says many of the older children have been assigned to nearby PS 111 and PS 51, which are struggling to cope with the influx of new students, most of whom do not speak English.
Rosenthal has been bringing the donated clothes and supplies to the Skyline and the schools for distribution and will continue to do so. âI think there has been an outpouring because people want to be of assistance, but they arenât sure how,â she says. âWeâve gotten some really nice stuff: coats, sweaters, toys, books, even a crib.â The recipients — who arrive with only the clothes on their backs — are so grateful, she said. âYou can see the desperation on their faces.â
Rosenthal’s donation drive ends next Friday, October 21st. You can drop off donations at her office at 230 West 72nd St, (Broadway and WEA), Suite 2F, until then. Next week, Assembly Member Danny OâDonnell, who represents the UWS north of 80th Street, will begin his own effort to help the migrant community, collecting toiletries, baby supplies, school supplies, winter wear, clothing, blankets, or backpacks at the Trinity Lutheran Church at 164 West 100th Street (Columbus and Amsterdam), on Wednesdays from October 26th-November 9th from 5pm-9pm, or on Saturdays from October 29th-November 12th from noon-5pm.
âThe biggest resource we have is the kindness and generosity of New Yorkers,â Rosenthal said. As for the governors and officials who keep sending the migrants north without any notice or regard for the outcome, she said, âI think judgment day will come for them, to have treated humans so despicably.â
looks like HousingWorks
Human trafficking: the unlawful act of transporting or coercing people in order to benefit from their work or service, typically in the form of forced labor or sexual exploitation.â
Weâre giving them piles of free goods and services. This isnât human trafficking at all
The act of giving them goods and clothing AFTER they are here is not the act of human trafficking. It’s busing them here that is the act of human trafficking.
They’re moved here with a ton a free things awaiting them, not work camps or sex rings. It’s not trafficking.
The people who end up here whether by plane or bus have no choice in where they are going. They are being used as political pawns–which is not the same has human trafficing, but still not what we should be tolerating as a country.
Biden administration flies them. Are you ready to call them human traffickers or it only applies to the mayors of overwhelmed cities who didnât vouch for it in the first place?
Aren’t the mayors of most if not all of the sanctuary cities to whom they are being sent, ardent supporters of the Biden administration and therefore support his “open borders,” policy?
Nobody is saying they support an open border policy. Being a sanctuary city means you dont use Homeland Security to hunt down people, based on immigration stays. That’s it. It has nothing to do with the policies on who gets in or how. You don’t like the current asylum laws, then ask Congress ro fix them. But neither Dems or Repubs want to do that.
We’ll let the voters decide in a few weeks whether or not they support the continuation of open borders, asylum for illegal aliens, and who controls Congress.
Yes, they are and they do.
However I meant the mayors of border towns who didnât declare their towns sanctuary, but are overwhelmed by millions of migrants. Not just 17000 like NYC where Adams for some reason welcomes migrant from Dem towns but bashes GOP mayors. Then complains.
I think the Biden administration would avoid calling them “migrants,” and instead call them “hopeful voters as soon as possible.”
I don’t get it. Why tricked and human trafficked? How are the people that are bussed different from the people that have been flown in by the feds for months now? What about busses that mayor Adams agreed to accept from a democratic mayor of El Paso? Why not being honest with yourself and your constituents? Why not call on federal government to show responsibility?
The federal government sends people to this area when they list NY/NJ as their final destination during processing at the border. That means that they have family connections here and do not end up in the shelter system. It also means they chose to come here.
The migrants arriving on buses sent by the governors of TX/FL/AZ usually do not know anyone here and often do not even know that theyâre coming here or were misled about whatâs awaiting them here. That is wrong.
Federal Government should have stopped people in their tracks. Which is what they are doing now when overwhelmed states started sending migrants to the doors of VP and such. This should have been done from the beginning!
“On Wednesday the US and Mexico announced a deal under which Venezuelan migrants who walk or swim across the southern border into America would be sent back.”
New York is screaming, “emergency” with 15,000 total arrivals. El Paso has Seven Thousand per week! Do you understand the impact that this has on the border communities?
https://app.powerbigov.us/view?r=eyJrIjoiNTlmOTY0ZDQtY2M0OS00OTY3LTk4MWQtMTVhYTJmZWIwMzQxIiwidCI6IjY2YThkY2Y5LWVkNzUtNGE2Zi04OGUwLTUxMGRmOWJkZjJhOSJ9
Whats wrong is people here support policies as long as they aren’t personally impacted. Now that a small number of ‘migrants’ are in NYC its an emergency. These people don’t know anyone in the US. .
You said donations end this Friday, October 21, but this Friday is the 14th. I’m hoping it runs until the 21sr as I making some infant and toddler blankets to donate–I’ll need unti next week to finish them.
Bless the blanket makers!
You are correct, the last day is NEXT Friday, Oct 21st… still a week left!
Dumb question, were the people forced onto the bus? Could they have just not gotten on?
Human trafficked indeed.
By the Mexican coyotes.
Tricked? How exactly?
Brought by a comfortable bus to NYC and other north cities, to be greeted with a free meal, a bed in a hotel, free education, health care, cloths, hey, lots of New Yorkers don’t get what these illegal migrants get, for free.
And lets not forget – please – that our own federal government has been flying them to northern towns in the middle of the night, for over a year already. To airports in White Plains, Weschester, Montgomery, Scranton, and others. So is the federal government guilty of human trafficking as well?
We are a sanctuary city & state.
Live with it or change our laws.