By Joy Bergmann
Although official parties refuse to confirm it, multiple sources indicate that The Esplanade Senior Residence at 305 West End Avenue is being sold to The Bristal Assisted Living, a conglomerate of supportive residences owned by The Engel Burman Group.
Thursday afternoon, WSR found The Esplanade’s lobby bustling with activity: a job fair for all positions was underway. And, according to two Esplanade staffers, current employees seeking to work for “the new owners” had to submit their resumes and be re-interviewed for their positions as well.
WSR asked the woman leading the job fair about the purported sale. “We don’t have any comment at this time,” she said. A current Esplanade manager would only say, “I don’t know if this is something that they want out there.”
They haven’t informed residents of any change in ownership, says Carol, whose 91 year-old mother-in-law has lived at The Esplanade for over four years, along with approximately 150 other seniors. Residents have their own studio or one-bedroom apartments, but also receive meals, cleaning services and access to health care aides; prices start at about $6000 per month.
Carol says she and her mother-in-law have noticed a decline in overall quality – especially food – over the past year and wonder whether any new owners will improve the situation, and at what cost. “It’s always a concern that prices will go up with someone new,” she says. Transparency would be welcomed, “The residents need to know.”
“A new owner will hopefully help to usher in a new age of responsibility at the Esplanade,” said Assemblymember Linda B. Rosenthal. “But it’s also crucial that residents be given ample notice of changes that have the potential to impact the quality and kind of service they are accustomed to receiving. Though State DOH does not oversee the sale of senior living facilities, I will work closely with stakeholders to ensure a seamless transition for my constituents.”
The Scharf family has owned and operated The Esplanade for decades, according to its web site. Recent years, however, have been troubled.
Two-year-old Greta Greene died in May 2015 after a piece of The Esplanade’s façade fell and hit her as she and her grandmother sat on a bench outside the building. An engineer was later convicted of signing off on a phony inspection report for the building and received probation.
And last month, criminal charges were filed against Esplanade Venture Partnership and Alexander Scharf for failing to maintain The Esplanade in a safe condition. The charges carry a maximum penalty of $25,000 or up to a year in jail, or both.
Alexander Scharf did not respond to WSR’s message. Nor did Marcy Levitt, the Esplanade’s current executive director. Nor did Ellen Antonucci, a marketing executive with The Bristal.
However, The Bristal’s own web site touts a new residence opening soon on the Upper West Side. A general inquiry about that new location garnered a phone call from a staffer. She wasn’t sure of the exact address, but, “It’s the old Esplanade building.”
Where is 305 West End?
It’s btwn 74 and 75, closer to 74.
Corner of 74th and West End avenue.
Originally Esplanade hotel current building spans lots 301-311 West End avenue.
The hotel apparently had its heyday in the 1940’s with some very nice views.
https://collections.mcny.org/Collection/%5B305-West-End-Avenue.-Esplanade-Hotel,-view-from-roof.%5D-24UAKVVCCSS.html
https://collections.mcny.org/Collection/305-West-End-Avenue.-Esplanade-Hotel.-View-from-Schwab-Chateau-garden-24UFQE7AM1Q.html
Back in the 1980’s there was a pretty good restaurant (Fandango) located there as well.
Usual MO for the Scharf family is to purchase a hotel and turn it whole or part into senior residence. IIRC their property out on Staten Island was once a hotel as well.
There appear to be 3 ‘Esplandes’ owned by the Sharfs. If you google ‘sharf family’ theres 1997 nyt article. Maybe they own other properties also. Anyway surmise each property is LLC & stands on its own business wise & what’s going on is that the legal settlement for the wrongful death (likely -hopefully- massive) required selling (as is) to comply likely at a commercial loss but enough to pay them out & financial hit left the building in need of new mgt w deeper pockets for repairs, etc. which appear to be global and ongoing. What do you think. Happy Halloween.
Almost every LL/property owner puts individual buildings under separate LLCs these days. Friend on the UES sees a new name on lease renewals almost like clockwork every five or so years.
IIRC from published media reports criminal charges are going to be brought against the owners of Esplanade relating to that poor little girl’s death. Maybe that is playing into things as well.
The Scharf family is up to something with their Westchester property as well:
https://www.lohud.com/story/news/local/westchester/white-plains/2015/12/07/seniors-out-white-plains-esplanade-re-purposing/76917696/?from=global&sessionKey=&autologin=
$6000 a month for a studio apartment at the Esplanade, and the quality is NOT first-rate??! What the hell is wrong with Scharf and the Management of this facility? Are they so obsessed with lining their pockets that they cut down the quality of FOOD for the residents of their facility? If this is what senior citizens have to look forward to, then the country is in far worse shape than can even be imagined! Small wonder that neither Scharf or his representatives would comment on the situation!
It is nothing short of outrageous that Alexander Scharf and his organization can permit the Esplanade’s services deteriorate, when residents are paying top dollar for those services! $6000 for a studio, and the FOOD is not first-rate??! What the hell is going on when senior citizens are taken advantage of to this extent……all because there are cretins like Scharf, who are so obsessed with lining their pockets? This man should be brought up on charges if he cannot provide services that are in line with the monthly costs that residents are paying!
There have been complaints about the quality of food served going back to 2013, so this is not exactly news.
This is the way it’s going for independently owned Assisted Living buildings. (same thing with medical offices and small practices). They are being gobbled up by either Bristal or Atria and folded into their system. $6000 is actually par for these types of living arrangements. It’s for folks who have saved their money, or who are wealthy. The buildings offer medical access, activities, meals, etc. Some places cost most than that!
Small medical practices are shutting down as many old school physicians don’t want to be bothered any longer. Changes recently enacted via Obamacare such as mandatory implementation of electronic medical records was the last straw for many older doctors.
Other medical offices/practices such as those staffed with younger physicians are simply seeing it being more cost effective to “work” for a large healthcare network. Again changes mandated by Obamacare are hastening the along.
What is not to like for a physician? Working for Mount Sinai, NYP, Northwell or whatever the hospital supplies nurses and other office staff, the equipment, takes care of billing and payments, pays the rent on space etc… Doctors just show up for “work” do what they have to do and then punch out.
Far as assisted living facilities IIRC both on the federal and many local government levels (including New York) new laws/rules regarding how things must be run are making such places more expensive to operate.
“What is not to like for a physician?”
As spokesman for physicians you may want to include 2 doctors that my family currently uses that are planning on ending their practice of medicine soon.
Welcome to the club!
Speak to any random ten persons in NYC and about five or more will say pretty much the same thing.
Part of this likely also rests in the demographics; older doctors are simply either fully retiring or (God forbid) dying.
Others both young and old are simply fed up with the increased bureaucracy and heavy handed role of insurers, Medicare and Medicaid. All that coming with ever decreasing reimbursement rates.
Younger physicians, especially females simply aren’t willing to be the “24/7” type of doctors of the older generation. Life/work balance debate is very much alive in the medical field as elsewhere. This is helping to drive the number of doctors going to “work” for various hospitals/healthcare networks. Instead of the headaches of running a private practice, they are choosing to “work” for Mount Sinai or whatever.
B.B.
Again, while some “are choosing to ‘work’ for Mount Sinai or whatever” others are quitting Medicine.
How’s that working for you?
Am thinking persons in this assisted living facility must be from outside Manhattan, and or their kids wanted the family apartment.
For six grand per month you can remain in your own condo, co-op or townhouse and hire all the services needed. Home heath aid, meals, etc…
Living in an assisted living facility near your family means more love.
Are families passe also?
Let the Market Rule!
“This is the way it’s going for independently owned Assisted Living buildings. (same thing with medical offices and small practices). They are being gobbled up”
…and this is sickening
and anti-social
and kinda’sucks
I heard the Esplanade was disgusting!!! Can’t believe they charge $6,000 a month. Food is supposed to be awful. Apartments are old.
Maybe a change in ownership will help, but at what price?????
Not to mention a sacred cow in the neighborhood, but isn’t it time we let the JHL building on 97th St out of the barn? New quality housing for seniors? We need more options for seniors, not less.